top of page

Two pluralisms, one room

Writer: Claire Thompson
Claire Thompson
3 days ago
6 min read

Pluralistic counselling and pluralistic art therapy sound like the same thing. They are not, and the difference matters. One is a whole way of thinking about what therapy can be. The other is what that way of thinking looks like inside art therapy. This post looks at each one separately.


Pluralistic counselling as an approach


Counselling has a long history of what Mick Cooper and John McLeod have called "schoolism", where therapists are trained in one model and then offer that same model to everyone who walks through the door, whether or not it actually fits (McLeod and Cooper, 2015). The pluralistic approach grew out of a reaction against that. Its founding idea is wonderfully simple. There is no single right way to do therapy, and different people are helped by different things at different times (Cooper and McLeod, 2007).


Notice what this is not. It is not a refusal to believe in anything, and it is not the therapist simply picking whichever technique takes their fancy that morning. Pluralistic therapy's founders are explicit about this distinction, arguing that unlike eclecticism, where techniques get used without much regard for where they came from, the pluralistic framework gives therapists a way to organise, compare and evaluate the different things they draw on (Cooper and McLeod, 2007). It is a set of principles that practitioners from any background can pick up and use (Cooper and McLeod, 2011). The spotlight moves from the therapist's favourite theory to the actual person in the room, and three commitments spell this out (Cooper and Dryden, 2016). First, openness across orientations. There are many ways of understanding why people struggle, and many ways of helping. Second, openness across clients. No off-the-peg therapy, because no two people are the same. Third, openness across perspectives. The client's expertise about their own life counts just as much as the therapist's expertise about therapy.


There is a deeper idea underneath all of this. Pluralism is the belief that big questions can honestly have several different answers, held together with an ethical commitment to valuing difference and a healthy wariness of anyone claiming to have the one true way (Cooper and Dryden, 2016). Cooper and McLeod turned that philosophy into a working framework for therapy, one that lets ideas and methods from a whole range of orientations sit side by side, and one designed to be studied as well as used (Cooper and McLeod, 2007). Philosophy first, framework beneath it, approach in the room.

In practice, the approach comes down to three questions, asked together rather than in a neat sequence (Cooper and McLeod, 2007).


• Goals. What does this person want from therapy?

• Tasks. What needs to happen, step by step, to get there?

• Methods. Which ways of working will actually suit this person, this week, for this task?


The answers are negotiated aloud. Pluralistic therapists clearly state what they can offer, ask what the client has already found helpful in their own life, and keep checking in as the work progresses (Cooper and Dryden, 2016). The relationship is collaborative by design, not by personality.


And pluralism does not ask therapists to be good at everything. Its founders expect them to have solid core counselling skills, real depth in at least one approach, and open-minded curiosity about the rest, rather than omni-competence across the board (McLeod and Cooper, 2015).


That is the approach. It belongs to counselling and psychotherapy generally. But approaches do not stay tidy once you bring them into a room with paints, clay and a table covered in newspaper. And that is where the two halves of this post meet.


What pluralism looks like when the method is art


Art therapy is a recognised form of psychotherapy in which artmaking works alongside talking as a primary way of communicating. It aims to ease distress and build insight and self-worth by supporting people to express complicated thoughts and feelings through making, especially the things that are hard to put into words (Edwards, 2014). People often assume they need to be good at art to come to art therapy; you do not.


Pluralistic art therapy is what you get when you take the goals, tasks and methods structure and apply it honestly inside that kind of therapy. And applying it honestly changes something important.


In a conventional art therapy session, artmaking is the primary method by definition, built into the profession's own understanding of what art therapy is (Edwards, 2014). Pluralistic art therapy questions that assumption, but not naively, because art therapy theory has never treated the image as a mere tool. Since the foundational work of art therapists such as Schaverien, the relationship in art therapy has been understood as a triangle of client, therapist and image, three parties in conversation, with the image holding a life of its own and drawing responses from both people in the room (Schaverien, 2000). The image is not something the client simply switches on and off. Even in a week of mostly talking, a picture made weeks ago can keep speaking.


So, what pluralism adds is not a denial of the triangle. It is a conversation about where the emphasis falls within it. Art therapy writers already recognise that the emphasis can shift between the different sides of this triangle, within a single session and over time (Edwards, 2014). A pluralistic art therapist makes that shift explicit and shared. The client helps decide, session by session, whether this hour belongs mainly to the talking side of the triangle, the making side, or both at once. Some weeks you might talk. Other weeks you might make art. The therapy fits the person, not the other way around.


The goals, tasks and methods structure maps onto art therapy more naturally than you might expect. A client's goal might be to express something they cannot yet say. The task might be to get it out of the body and into a form that can be looked at. The method, negotiated rather than fixed, might be paint rather than clay today, quick sketches rather than one careful image, or no image at all this week. What pluralism adds is the explicit conversation about that choice, with the client's preferences treated as expertise rather than as noise.


There are two further shifts, and they are where the pluralistic stance really earns its keep. First, openness across perspectives extends to the artwork itself. The client's reading of their own image outranks the therapist's interpretation of it. Second, the menu of methods widens beyond the therapy room. A pluralistic approach draws on what already helps in a person's actual life: walking, music, faith, friendships, alongside what happens in sessions (McLeod and Cooper, 2015). In art therapy terms, that might mean the sketchbook that lives in their bag counts, not just the materials in my room.


This is not an invented combination, either. Work is already happening where pluralism and the arts meet. Arts for the Blues, for example, is a pluralistic group therapy for depression that blends evidence-based approaches with creative methods, built around ingredients that clients themselves said made therapy helpful (Omylinska-Thurston et al., 2020). Practitioners are also writing reflectively about what a pluralistic stance looks like inside art psychotherapy, from a deep respect for the person and their art to being honest about when a different therapy might serve someone better (Pluralistic Practice, 2019). The conversation is only just starting, which is part of what makes it interesting to write about.


Where the two stand


So here is the relationship, stated plainly. Pluralistic counselling is an approach to therapy grounded in a pluralistic philosophy and organised by the goals, tasks and methods framework (Cooper and Dryden, 2016; Cooper and McLeod, 2007). Pluralistic art therapy is one way of living that approach out within a specific discipline, one with its own professional standards, its own training routes and its own particular power, the power of image and making when words run out. Same philosophy. Different practice base.


Strip everything else away, and this is the heart of it. In both, the first question is never "which model do I believe in?" It is "what does this person need, and how will we find out together?"


References


Cooper, M. and Dryden, W. (2016) The handbook of pluralistic counselling and psychotherapy. London: Sage.

Cooper, M. and McLeod, J. (2007) 'A pluralistic framework for counselling and psychotherapy: Implications for research', Counselling and Psychotherapy Research, 7(3), pp. 135–143. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1080/14733140701566282.

Cooper, M. and McLeod, J. (2011) Pluralistic counselling and psychotherapy. London: Sage.

Edwards, D. (2014) 'What is art therapy?', in Art therapy. 2nd edn. London: Sage. Available at: https://doi.org/10.4135/9781526401533.

McLeod, J. and Cooper, M. (2015) 'Pluralistic counselling and psychotherapy', in The beginner's guide to counselling and psychotherapy. London: Sage, pp. 322–332. Available at: https://doi.org/10.4135/9781473918061.n25.

Omylinska-Thurston, J. et al. (2020) 'Arts for the Blues: The development of a new evidence-based creative group psychotherapy for depression', Counselling and Psychotherapy Research, 21(3), pp. 597–607. Available at: https://doi.org/10.1002/capr.12373.

Pluralistic Practice (2019) Pluralistic art psychotherapy: valuing diverse lenses. Available at: https://pluralisticpractice.com/main-blog/training/pluralistic-art-psychotherapy-valuing-diverse-lenses/ (Accessed: 13 November 2026).

Schaverien, J. (2000) 'The triangular relationship and the aesthetic countertransference in analytical art psychotherapy', in The changing shape of art therapy. London: Jessica Kingsley.

 


 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page